Managing Higher Education for Relevance and Efficiency

Abstract*

The Project for Managing Higher Education for Relevance and Efficiency seeks to create an enabling environment for the evolution of autonomous, and accountable public higher education institutions (HEIs), and to develop effective support mechanisms for the improvement of the quality, relevance, efficiency, and equity of higher education. The project comprises two components: 1) The first component will support the Government in the to implementation... Show More

Development Objective

To create an enabling environment for the evolution of autonomous public higher education institutions (HEIs), and to develop effective support mechanisms for the improvement of the quality, relevance, efficiency, and equity of higher education.

Key Details

Project Details

Project ID
P085374
Status
Closed
Team Leader
Ratna Kesuma
Borrower 2
N/A

Country
Indonesia
Disclosure Date
March 4, 2004
Approval Date
(as of board presentation)
June 9, 2005
Effective Date
December 20, 2005

Total Project Cost 1
US$ 114.54 million
Implementing Agency
N/A
Region
East Asia and Pacific
Fiscal Year 3
2005

Commitment Amount
US$ 80.00 million
Environmental Category
C
Environmental and Social Risk
Not Applicable
Closing Date
December 31, 2012

Last Stage Reached
BANK APPROVED
Last Update Date
August 15, 2023

Notes
1. Total project cost includes funding from World Bank and non-bank sources in US$ millions. Active and Closed projects show current commitments. Proposed (pipeline) and dropped projects show the forecast amount. The commitment amount for projects in the pipeline is indicative and may be modified during the project preparation.
2. Borrower refers to the Borrower of a Loan or Recipient of a Grant.
3. ”Fiscal Year” is the fiscal year in which the project was approved (or dropped if the status is dropped). The World Bank's fiscal year is from July 1 - June 30. For example, a fiscal year of 1996 corresponds to July 1, 1995 - June 30, 1996.

Sectors

Themes

FY17 - Human Development and Gender

FY17 - Education40%
- FY17 - Access to Education10%
- FY17 - Science and Technology10%
- FY17 - Standards, Curriculum and Textbooks10%
- FY17 - Teachers10%

FY17 - Public Sector Management

FY17 - Public Administration40%
- FY17 - Administrative and Civil Service Reform20%
- FY17 - Municipal Institution Building20%
FY17 - Rule of Law21%
- FY17 - Judicial and other Dispute Resolution Mechanisms7%
- FY17 - Legal Institutions for a Market Economy7%
- FY17 - Personal and Property Rights7%

Project Map

Interactive Map

Finances

Financing Plan (US$ Millions)

Financier	Commitments
IDA Credit	30.00
International Bank for Reconstruction and Development	50.00
Borrower/Recipient	34.54

Total Project Financing (US$ Millions)

Product Line	IBRD/IDA
IBRD Commitment	50.00
IDA Commitment	30.00
IBRD + IDA Commitment	80.00

Lending Instrument
Grant Amount	N/A
Total Project Cost**	114.54

Summary Status of World Bank Financing (US$ Millions) as of April 30, 2025

No data available.

Detailed Financial Activity as of April 30, 2025

Download:

Period	Financier	Transaction Type	Amount (US$)
May 15, 2020	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,343,368.00
May 15, 2020	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	673,947.06
May 15, 2020	IDA-40770	Int Charges	48,018.74
May 15, 2020	IDA-40770	Int Charges	48,018.74
Nov 15, 2019	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	676,066.50
Nov 15, 2019	IDA-40770	Int Charges	50,394.09
Nov 15, 2019	IDA-40770	Int Charges	50,394.09
Nov 15, 2019	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	273,730.70
Nov 15, 2019	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,320,727.00
Nov 15, 2019	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	5,376.62
May 15, 2022	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	1,297,918.40
May 15, 2022	IDA-40770	Int Charges	34,637.28
May 15, 2022	IDA-40770	Int Charges	34,637.28
May 15, 2022	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	21,597.68
Nov 15, 2021	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	43,436.22
Nov 15, 2021	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,411,291.10
Nov 15, 2021	IDA-40770	Int Charges	41,791.50
Nov 15, 2021	IDA-40770	Int Charges	41,791.50
Nov 15, 2021	IDA-40770	Int Charges	5,275.10
Nov 15, 2021	IDA-40770	Int Charges	5,275.10
Nov 15, 2021	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	1,393,049.00
Nov 15, 2020	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	87,298.27
Nov 15, 2020	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,366,009.00
Nov 15, 2020	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	693,928.10
Nov 15, 2020	IDA-40770	Int Charges	45,830.70
Nov 15, 2020	IDA-40770	Int Charges	45,830.70
May 15, 2021	IDA-40770	Int Charges	40,068.82
May 15, 2021	IDA-40770	Int Charges	40,068.82
May 15, 2021	IDA-40770	Int Charges	1,705.36
May 15, 2021	IDA-40770	Int Charges	1,705.36
May 15, 2021	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	713,266.70
May 15, 2021	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	49,699.94
May 15, 2021	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,388,650.00
Nov 15, 2014	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	87,828.97
Nov 15, 2014	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,124,036.40
Nov 15, 2014	IDA-40770	Int Charges	92,547.08
Nov 15, 2014	IDA-40770	Int Charges	92,547.08
Nov 15, 2014	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	4,794.96
Nov 15, 2014	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	721,064.30
May 15, 2023	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	12,797.17
May 15, 2023	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	190,135.42
May 15, 2023	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,482,987.80
May 15, 2023	IDA-40770	Int Charges	21,784.81
May 15, 2023	IDA-40770	Int Charges	21,784.81
May 15, 2023	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	1,331,305.50
May 15, 2023	IDA-40770	Int Charges	13,240.92
May 15, 2023	IDA-40770	Int Charges	13,240.92
Nov 15, 2022	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	135,547.38
Nov 15, 2022	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,456,573.10
Nov 15, 2022	IDA-40770	Int Charges	8,007.19
Nov 15, 2022	IDA-40770	Int Charges	8,007.19
Nov 15, 2022	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	49,413.27
Nov 15, 2022	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	1,255,428.00
May 15, 2022	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	39,813.46
May 15, 2022	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,433,932.10
Jun 9, 2005	IDA-40770	Loan Commitment	30,000,000.00
Jun 9, 2005	IBRD-47890	Loan Commitment	50,000,000.00
May 15, 2024	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	1,219.51
May 15, 2024	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	148,466.48
May 15, 2024	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,532,043.20
May 15, 2024	IDA-40770	Int Charges	7,727.87
May 15, 2024	IDA-40770	Int Charges	7,727.87
May 15, 2024	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	1,312,129.10
May 15, 2024	IDA-40770	Int Charges	14,761.42
May 15, 2024	IDA-40770	Int Charges	14,761.42
Nov 15, 2023	IDA-40770	Int Charges	11,578.65
Nov 15, 2023	IDA-40770	Int Charges	11,578.65
Nov 15, 2023	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	1,315,133.50
Nov 15, 2023	IDA-40770	Int Charges	11,981.45
Nov 15, 2023	IDA-40770	Int Charges	11,981.45
Nov 15, 2023	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	4,593.67
Nov 15, 2023	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	185,513.75
Nov 15, 2023	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,509,402.20
Sep 29, 2016	IBRD-47890	Loan Disb	-130,062.00
Sep 29, 2016	IBRD-47890	Loan Cancel	130,062.00
Nov 15, 2016	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	22.59
Nov 15, 2016	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	162,058.38
Nov 15, 2016	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,199,984.80
Nov 15, 2016	IDA-40770	Int Charges	76,051.07
Nov 15, 2016	IDA-40770	Int Charges	76,051.07
Jan 17, 2017	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	1,345,256.60
May 15, 2019	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	11,364.43
May 15, 2019	IDA-40770	Int Charges	55,682.24
May 15, 2019	IDA-40770	Int Charges	55,682.24
May 15, 2019	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	313,796.56
May 15, 2019	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,298,085.90
May 15, 2019	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	673,955.60
Nov 15, 2018	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	13,594.21
Jan 15, 2019	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	1,383,520.20
Nov 15, 2018	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	671,398.60
Nov 15, 2018	IDA-40770	Int Charges	61,649.31
Nov 15, 2018	IDA-40770	Int Charges	61,649.31
Nov 15, 2018	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	304,041.06
Nov 15, 2018	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,275,444.90
May 15, 2018	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	220,830.73
May 15, 2018	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,256,577.40
May 15, 2018	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	6,004.59
May 15, 2018	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	702,066.44
May 15, 2018	IDA-40770	Int Charges	66,381.64
May 15, 2018	IDA-40770	Int Charges	66,381.64
Nov 15, 2020	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	9,978.41
May 15, 2020	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	194,953.39
May 15, 2020	IDA-40770	Int Charges	706.30
May 15, 2020	IDA-40770	Int Charges	706.30
May 15, 2015	IDA-40770	Int Charges	61,763.28
May 15, 2015	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	88,851.51
May 15, 2015	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,143,023.50
May 15, 2015	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	19,922.14
May 15, 2015	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	682,080.60
May 15, 2015	IDA-40770	Int Charges	61,763.28
May 15, 2014	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	764,653.44
May 15, 2014	IDA-40770	Int Charges	100,360.76
May 15, 2014	IDA-40770	Int Charges	100,360.76
May 15, 2014	IDA-40770	Int Charges	5,044.10
May 15, 2014	IDA-40770	Int Charges	5,044.10
May 15, 2014	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	95,800.13
May 15, 2014	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,105,049.20
Nov 15, 2013	IDA-40770	Int Charges	-0.02
Nov 15, 2013	IDA-40770	Int Charges	0.02
Nov 15, 2013	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	9,262.08
Nov 15, 2013	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	748,217.50
Nov 15, 2013	IDA-40770	Int Charges	97,263.50
Nov 15, 2013	IDA-40770	Int Charges	97,263.50
Nov 15, 2013	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	1,010.54
Nov 15, 2013	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	110,643.93
Nov 15, 2013	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,086,062.10
Jun 2, 2016	IBRD-47890	Loan Disb	-19,930.00
May 15, 2016	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	15,138.58
May 15, 2016	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	684,380.40
May 15, 2016	IDA-40770	Int Charges	71,783.92
May 15, 2016	IDA-40770	Int Charges	71,783.92
May 15, 2016	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	124,500.62
May 15, 2016	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,180,997.60
Jun 2, 2016	IBRD-47890	Loan Cancel	19,930.00
Nov 15, 2015	IDA-40770	Int Charges	24,543.88
Nov 15, 2015	IDA-40770	Int Charges	24,543.88
Nov 15, 2015	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	686,187.60
Nov 15, 2015	IDA-40770	Int Charges	82,342.49
Nov 15, 2015	IDA-40770	Int Charges	82,342.49
Nov 15, 2015	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	102,084.74
Nov 15, 2015	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,162,010.50
Nov 15, 2017	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	215,742.23
Nov 15, 2017	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,233,936.40
Nov 15, 2017	IDA-40770	Int Charges	11,713.89
Nov 15, 2017	IDA-40770	Int Charges	11,713.89
Nov 15, 2017	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	700,495.60
Nov 15, 2017	IDA-40770	Int Charges	68,298.33
Nov 15, 2017	IDA-40770	Int Charges	68,298.33
May 15, 2017	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	-125.26
May 15, 2017	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	83.51
May 15, 2017	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	41.75
May 15, 2017	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	197,292.73
May 15, 2017	IBRD-47890	Loan Repay	1,215,068.80
May 15, 2017	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	20,523.25
May 15, 2017	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	658,862.40
May 15, 2017	IDA-40770	Int Charges	59,181.98
May 15, 2017	IDA-40770	Int Charges	59,181.98
May 15, 2017	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	19.16
Nov 15, 2016	IDA-40770	Int Charges	9,214.71
Nov 15, 2016	IDA-40770	Int Charges	9,214.71
Nov 15, 2016	IDA-40770	Loan Repay	676,009.44
May 15, 2017	IBRD-47890	Int Charges	196.50

Footnotes

Ratings

IMPLEMENTATION RATINGS

Name	Review	Date
Progress towards achievement of PDO	Moderately Satisfactory	2012-12-25
Counterpart Funding	Moderately Satisfactory	2012-12-25
Overall Implementation Progress (IP)	Moderately Satisfactory	2012-12-25
Project Management	Moderately Satisfactory	2012-12-25
Procurement	Moderately Satisfactory	2012-12-25
Financial Management	Moderately Satisfactory	2012-12-25
Monitoring and Evaluation	Moderately Unsatisfactory	2012-12-25

COMPLETION RATINGS

INDICATOR	IMPLEMENTATION COMPLETION & RESULTS REPORT: 06-26-2013
Outcomes	Moderately Satisfactory
Risk to Development Outcome	Substantial
Bank Performance	Moderately Satisfactory
Borrower Performance	Moderately Satisfactory
Government Performance	Moderately Unsatisfactory
Implementing Agency	Moderately Satisfactory

INDEPENDENT EVALUATION RATINGS

INDICATOR	ICR REVIEW: 01-02-2014	PROJECT PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT REPORT: 06-18-2015
Outcome Rating	Moderately Satisfactory	Moderately Satisfactory
Risk To Development Outcome	Significant	Substantial
Bank Performance	Moderately Satisfactory	Moderately Satisfactory
Borrower Performance	Moderately Satisfactory	Moderately Satisfactory
Government Performance	Moderately Unsatisfactory	Not Rated
Implementing Agency	Moderately Satisfactory	Moderately Satisfactory
Icr Quality	Satisfactory	Not Rated
M&e Quality	Modest	Modest

Results Framework

PROJECT DEVELOPMENT OBJECTIVE INDICATORS

INDICATOR		BASELINE	CURRENT	TARGET

The draft law on education institutions (BHP) is passed by 2010.	Value	Draft available discussed at ministrial level.	Achieved with delay - New law UU12/2012 passed to	New law promulgated by 2010.
	Date	December 20, 2005	August 10, 2012	December 31, 2012
	Comment

The National Information System for Higher Education develops the capability to conduct and report on regular graduate tracer studies by the Project Closing Date.	Value	Zero	Partially Achieved - All design elements are compl	NISHE develops capability to conduct and report on
	Date	December 20, 2005	November 26, 2012	December 31, 2012
	Comment		Bank review expressed concerns with the nature of questions and DGHE has agreed to revise for future data collection.

Institutional accreditation is awarded to five percent of all public HEIs by 2010.	Value	None	Target is substantially exceeded - after a hiatus	5% of 82 Public HEIs accredited by 2010.
	Date	December 20, 2005	November 26, 2012	December 31, 2010
	Comment

Unqualified opinion awarded by external auditors on financial audits to 5 public HEIs.	Value	None	Achieved - Institutional status clarified by UU12/	Unqualified opinion awarded to 5 BHMNs on financia
	Date	December 20, 2005	November 26, 2012	September 30, 2012
	Comment

A comprehensive process evaluation of line item financing, competitive grants, and performance-based contracting is completed by the Project Closing Date.	Value	Zero	Not Met - DGHE has belatedly acknowledged the pote	Evaluation is completed by 2010.
	Date	December 20, 2005	November 26, 2012	December 31, 2012
	Comment

Ninety percent of procurement carried out by the participating institutions is awarded within the bid validity period.	Value	None	Target Exceeded - 17 of the 19 HEI (90%) for which	90% of procurement activities are completed within
	Date	December 20, 2005	November 26, 2012	December 31, 2012
	Comment

Fifty percent of procurement staff of participating institutions is certified in accordance with national certification policy in existence in 2010.	Value	None	Target Exceeded - 15 of the 19 HEI (79%) report su	50% of procurement staff at all participating HEIs
	Date	December 20, 2005	November 26, 2012	December 31, 2012
	Comment

All participating institutions publish all records of contracted unit rates for goods and major construction materials for contracts above USD 50,000 equivalent.	Value	None	Target not met - 8 of the 19 (42%) report publishi	All records of contracted unit rates for goods and
	Date	December 20, 2005	November 26, 2012	August 1, 2012
	Comment		Information was not available from 4 HEI.

INTERMEDIATE RESULTS INDICATORS

INDICATOR		BASELINE	CURRENT	TARGET

Efficiency: A 10% reduction effort in the time to graduate by students of grantee HEIs.	Value	57.4 months	Target Exceeded - Reported average months to gradu	A 10% reduction effort in the time to graduate by
	Date	January 31, 2006	November 26, 2012	August 1, 2012
	Comment		The Bank team continues to have concerns about the way in which data is collected and analyzed.

Equity: A 50% increase in the number of students from low income families (lowest quintile) receiving scholarships in grantee HEIs.	Value	8% of student population	Achieved - Variable for individual HEIs but with a	A 50% increase in the number of students from low
	Date	January 31, 2006	November 26, 2012	December 31, 2012
	Comment		The Bank team has concerns about the way “poor” is defined and doubts the figure attained is representative of the lowest incomequintile.

Quality: A 5% increase in the average GPA of students graduating from grantee HEIs.	Value	2.98	Achieved - Reported increase to average GPA of 3.2	A 5% increase in the average GPA of students gradu
	Date	January 31, 2006	November 26, 2012	December 31, 2012
	Comment

Relevance: A 10% reduction in the time taken to find first employment by graduates from grantee HEIs.	Value	8.7 months	Achieved – although with wide variation across HEI	A 10% reduction in the time taken to find first em
	Date	January 31, 2006	September 30, 2012	December 28, 2012
	Comment