Economic Governance Technical

Abstract*

The objective of the Economic Governance Technical Assistance Project is to increase the efficiency, accountability, and transparency of public financial management to Comoros and to improve the management of civil service human resources and wages. This project has four components. Component one involves rationalizing the project preparation facility's (PFM) institutional frameworks and processes. The component has the following three sub-components:... Show More

Development Objective

To increase the efficiency, accountability and transparency of public financial management and to improve the management of civil service human resources and wages.

Key Details

Project Details

Project ID
P102376
Status
Closed
Team Leader
Anne-Lucie Lefebvre
Borrower 2
Cellule Chargee du Suivi des Reformes Economiques et Financieres (CREF),Ministry of Finance

Country
Comoros
Disclosure Date
November 4, 2010
Approval Date
(as of board presentation)
January 31, 2011
Effective Date
February 28, 2011

Total Project Cost 1
US$ 1.80 million
Implementing Agency
ABGE Projet d'Appui la Bonne Gouvernance Economique
Region
Eastern and Southern Africa
Fiscal Year 3
2011

Commitment Amount
US$ 1.80 million
Environmental Category
C
Environmental and Social Risk
Not Applicable
Closing Date
December 31, 2016

Last Stage Reached
BANK APPROVED
Last Update Date
December 16, 2016

Associated Projects
P144381

Notes
1. Total project cost includes funding from World Bank and non-bank sources in US$ millions. Active and Closed projects show current commitments. Proposed (pipeline) and dropped projects show the forecast amount. The commitment amount for projects in the pipeline is indicative and may be modified during the project preparation.
2. Borrower refers to the Borrower of a Loan or Recipient of a Grant.
3. ”Fiscal Year” is the fiscal year in which the project was approved (or dropped if the status is dropped). The World Bank's fiscal year is from July 1 - June 30. For example, a fiscal year of 1996 corresponds to July 1, 1995 - June 30, 1996.

Sectors

Themes

FY17 - Private Sector Development

FY17 - Enterprise Development13%
- FY17 - MSME Development13%

FY17 - Public Sector Management

FY17 - Public Administration56%
- FY17 - Administrative and Civil Service Reform25%
- FY17 - Transparency, Accountability and Good Governance31%
FY17 - Public Finance Management31%
- FY17 - Public Expenditure Management31%

Project Map

Interactive Map

Finances

Financing Plan (US$ Millions)

Financier	Commitments
IDA Grant	1.80

Total Project Financing (US$ Millions)

Product Line	IBRD/IDA
IBRD Commitment	N/A
IDA Commitment	1.80
IBRD + IDA Commitment	1.80

Lending Instrument
Grant Amount	N/A
Total Project Cost**	1.80

Summary Status of World Bank Financing (US$ Millions) as of July 31, 2025

No data available.

Detailed Financial Activity as of July 31, 2025

Download:

Period	Financier	Transaction Type	Amount (US$)
Sep 17, 2014	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	15,691.53
Mar 25, 2015	IDA-H6460	Loan Disb	327.76
May 29, 2015	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	85,036.29
Apr 21, 2015	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	15,646.62
Jul 16, 2015	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	97,482.54
Aug 7, 2015	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	62,759.30
Dec 10, 2014	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	82,840.56
Oct 28, 2014	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	58,203.10
Nov 26, 2014	IDA-H6460	Loan Disb	52,545.10
Jan 2, 2014	IDA-H6460	Loan Disb	33,803.63
Nov 4, 2013	IDA-H6460	Loan Disb	77,558.96
Feb 13, 2014	IDA-H6460	Loan Disb	141,765.19
Jan 31, 2011	IDA-H6460	Loan Commitment	1,800,000.00
Nov 12, 2013	IDA-H8870	Loan Commitment	3,500,000.00
Mar 13, 2014	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	411,213.94
Jun 20, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	101,547.64
Oct 26, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	20,710.27
Jun 28, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	225,131.66
Dec 13, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	15,744.87
May 27, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	57,404.86
Nov 7, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	25,087.88
Aug 9, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	7,224.37
Sep 12, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	29,662.43
Sep 27, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	7,263.47
Dec 22, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	62,372.46
Jun 3, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	117,234.13
Mar 9, 2017	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	-142.50
Mar 9, 2017	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	-29,295.76
Apr 30, 2017	IDA-H8870	Loan Cancel	43,194.75
May 18, 2015	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	43,108.61
Nov 16, 2015	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	137,634.12
Oct 1, 2015	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	90,826.03
Nov 2, 2015	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	68,331.70
Oct 29, 2015	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	85,324.81
Feb 4, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	26,363.30
Feb 4, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	47,912.05
Dec 3, 2015	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	258,336.58
Feb 26, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	31,368.31
Mar 22, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	153,607.19
Mar 1, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	90,589.13
Jul 28, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	10,195.74
May 2, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	72,357.47
May 2, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	56,384.75
Apr 14, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	97,653.42
Aug 12, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	9,514.56
Jun 30, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	79,100.65
Jul 20, 2016	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	222,475.62
Apr 4, 2014	IDA-H6460	Loan Disb	12,980.35
Sep 15, 2014	IDA-H6460	Loan Disb	23,960.76
Feb 18, 2015	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	16,980.71
Mar 27, 2015	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	61,756.88
Mar 11, 2015	IDA-H6460	Loan Disb	9,506.61
Aug 20, 2014	IDA-H6460	Loan Disb	129,910.06
Aug 13, 2014	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	7,142.80
Jul 30, 2014	IDA-H8870	Loan Disb	82,511.36

Footnotes

Ratings

IMPLEMENTATION RATINGS

Name	Review	Date
Procurement	Moderately Satisfactory	2016-11-16
Financial Management	Moderately Satisfactory	2016-11-16
Monitoring and Evaluation	Moderately Satisfactory	2016-11-16
Overall Implementation Progress (IP)	Moderately Unsatisfactory	2016-11-16
Progress towards achievement of PDO	Moderately Unsatisfactory	2016-11-16
Project Management	Moderately Satisfactory	2016-11-16

COMPLETION RATINGS

INDICATOR	IMPLEMENTATION COMPLETION & RESULTS REPORT: 06-27-2017
Outcomes	Unsatisfactory
Risk to Development Outcome	Substantial
Bank Performance	Moderately Satisfactory
Borrower Performance	Moderately Unsatisfactory
Government Performance	Moderately Unsatisfactory
Implementing Agency	Moderately Satisfactory

INDEPENDENT EVALUATION RATINGS

INDICATOR	ICR REVIEW: 12-18-2017	PROJECT PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT REPORT:
Outcome Rating	Unsatisfactory	N/a
Risk To Development Outcome	Substantial	N/a
Bank Performance	Moderately Unsatisfactory	N/a
Borrower Performance	Moderately Unsatisfactory	N/a
Government Performance	Unsatisfactory	N/a
Implementing Agency	Moderately Satisfactory	N/a
Icr Quality	Modest	N/a
M&e Quality	Modest	N/a

Results Framework

PROJECT DEVELOPMENT OBJECTIVE INDICATORS

INDICATOR		BASELINE	CURRENT	TARGET

Budget execution reports published (on the web or national media) regularly (PEFA PI-10) Value D+ D B+
Date January 31, 2011 September 30, 2016 June 30, 2016
Comment
Share of civil servants paid through the automated payroll system Value 0.00 87.00 95.00
Date January 31, 2011 September 30, 2015 June 30, 2016
Comment

Public access to key sectoral fiscal information	Value	N/A (PI-10 rate D+)	PI-10 rated D with Sector Budget Execution Reports	PI-10 rated B+ with Sector Budget Execution Report
	Date	November 12, 2013	September 30, 2016	June 30, 2016
	Comment

INTERMEDIATE RESULTS INDICATORS

INDICATOR		BASELINE	CURRENT	TARGET

New organic law for PFM prepared for adoption Value No Yes Yes.
Date January 31, 2011 September 30, 2016 June 30, 2016
Comment
Enhanced computerization of budget management and reporting (PEFA P1-24). Value D D+ B
Date January 31, 2011 September 30, 2016 June 30, 2016
Comment

Publication of public tender procurement notice for any public procurement financed by the national budget or by donors according to law No. 11-027/AU	Value	0.00	39.00	90.00
	Date	November 12, 2013	September 30, 2016	June 30, 2016
	Comment

Comprehensive strategy for civil service management reform is adopted Value No Yes Yes
Date November 12, 2013 September 30, 2016 June 30, 2016
Comment

Enhanced efficiency in controls of civil service wage bill accuracy (through cross checks across databases, timely updates, and internal controls) (PEFA PI-18))	Value	D	D+	B+
	Date	January 31, 2011	September 30, 2016	June 30, 2016
	Comment

Annual budget prepared in timely manner (PEFA PI-11) Value D+ B B
Date January 31, 2011 September 30, 2016 June 30, 2016
Comment
Limited use of budgetary adjustments during the FY (PEFA PI-16) Value D+ C+ C+
Date January 31, 2011 September 30, 2016 June 30, 2016
Comment

New organic law for PFM prepared for adoption	Value	No	Yes	Yes.
	Date	January 31, 2011	September 30, 2016	June 30, 2016
	Comment