Skip to Main Navigation

Ethiopia Protection of Basic Services Program Phase II Project

Abstract*

The objective of the Second Phase of the Protection of Basic Services Program Project (PBSII) is to contribute to expanding access and improving the quality of basic services in education, health, agriculture, water supply and sanitation, and rural roads delivered by subnational governments in Ethiopia, while continuing to deepen transparency and local accountability in service delivery. Four subprograms are the components of this project. Subprogram...

* The project abstract is drawn from the PAD, SAR or PGD and may not accurately reflect the project's current nature

Show More

Development Objective

The Development Objective of the Ethiopia Protection of Basic Services Program Phase II Project (PBS II) is to contribute to expanding access and improving the quality of basic services in education, health, agriculture, water supply and sanitation, and rural roads delivered by sub-national governments, while continuing to deepen transparency and local accountability in service delivery.

Key Details

Project Details

  • P103022

  • Closed

  • Camilla Holmemo

  • N/A

  • Ethiopia

  • August 25, 2008

  • (as of board presentation)

    May 14, 2009

  • May 22, 2009

  • US$ 1278.00 million

  • B

  • August 19, 2014

  • June 30, 2013

  • BANK APPROVED

  • Notes

Finances

Financing Plan (US$ Millions)

No data available.
Financier Commitments
UK: British Department for International Development (DFID) 295.90
AUSTRIA, Govt. of: Fed Chancellery - Dir Gen Dev Coop. 10.90
Borrower/Recipient 1428.60
SPAIN, Govt. of 40.70
GERMANY: KREDITANSTALT FUR WIEDERAUFBAU (KFW) 47.50
EC: European Commission 67.30
IRELAND, Govt. of 32.90
ITALY: Dev. Coop. Department (MOFA) 10.20
Borrowing Agency 657.50
IDA Grant 309.78
IDA Credit 230.22
NETHERLANDS: Min. of Foreign Affairs / Min. of Dev. Coop. 10.90
CANADA: Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) 59.80
African Development Bank 161.90

Total Project Financing (US$ Millions)

Product Line IBRD/IDA
IBRD Commitment N/A
IDA Commitment 540.00
IBRD + IDA Commitment 540.00
Lending Instrument
Grant Amount 738.00
Total Project Cost** 3364.10

Summary Status of World Bank Financing (US$ Millions) as of March 31, 2025

Download:
No data available.
Financier Approval Date Closing Date Principal Disbursed Repayments Interest, Charges & Fees

Detailed Financial Activity as of March 31, 2025

Download:
No data available.
Period Financier Transaction Type Amount (US$)
Nov 15, 2014 IDA-48670 Int Charges 620,610.40
Nov 15, 2014 IDA-48670 Int Charges 620,610.40
Nov 1, 2014 IDA-45780 Int Charges 3,073.49
Nov 1, 2014 IDA-45780 Int Charges 3,073.49
Nov 1, 2014 IDA-45780 Int Charges 855,398.70
Nov 1, 2014 IDA-45780 Int Charges 855,398.70
May 1, 2017 IDA-45780 Int Charges 769,677.50
May 1, 2017 IDA-45780 Int Charges 769,677.50
Nov 15, 2017 IDA-48670 Int Charges 9,126.59
Nov 15, 2017 IDA-48670 Int Charges 9,126.59
Nov 15, 2017 IDA-48670 Int Charges 602,442.30
Nov 15, 2017 IDA-48670 Int Charges 602,442.30
Nov 1, 2017 IDA-45780 Int Charges 813,026.00
Nov 1, 2017 IDA-45780 Int Charges 813,026.00
Nov 1, 2017 IDA-45780 Int Charges 12,455.68
Nov 1, 2017 IDA-45780 Int Charges 12,455.68
May 15, 2017 IDA-48670 Int Charges 19,196.74
May 15, 2017 IDA-48670 Int Charges 19,196.74
May 15, 2017 IDA-48670 Int Charges 556,238.94
May 15, 2017 IDA-48670 Int Charges 556,238.94
Nov 1, 2016 IDA-45780 Int Charges 25,026.69
May 15, 2016 IDA-48670 Int Charges 11,623.37
May 15, 2016 IDA-48670 Int Charges 11,623.37
May 15, 2016 IDA-48670 Int Charges 582,632.50
May 15, 2016 IDA-48670 Int Charges 582,632.50
Nov 18, 2016 IDA-48670 Int Charges 7,059.35
Nov 18, 2016 IDA-48670 Int Charges 7,059.35
Nov 18, 2016 IDA-48670 Int Charges 578,092.00
Nov 18, 2016 IDA-48670 Int Charges 578,092.00
Nov 1, 2015 IDA-45780 Int Charges 69.42
Nov 1, 2015 IDA-45780 Int Charges 69.42
Nov 4, 2015 IDA-45780 Int Charges 806,123.20
Nov 4, 2015 IDA-45780 Int Charges 806,123.20
Nov 1, 2016 IDA-45780 Int Charges 25,026.69
Nov 1, 2016 IDA-45780 Int Charges 797,171.70
Nov 1, 2016 IDA-45780 Int Charges 797,171.70
May 1, 2016 IDA-45780 Int Charges 8,430.38
May 1, 2016 IDA-45780 Int Charges 8,430.38
May 3, 2016 IDA-45780 Int Charges 791,298.80
May 3, 2016 IDA-45780 Int Charges 791,298.80
Nov 15, 2015 IDA-48670 Int Charges 18,783.79
Nov 15, 2015 IDA-48670 Int Charges 18,783.79
Nov 15, 2015 IDA-48670 Int Charges 590,137.10
Nov 15, 2015 IDA-48670 Int Charges 590,137.10
May 1, 2015 IDA-45780 Int Charges 23,257.21
May 1, 2015 IDA-45780 Int Charges 23,257.21
May 15, 2015 IDA-48670 Int Charges 15,196.00
May 15, 2015 IDA-48670 Int Charges 15,196.00
May 15, 2015 IDA-48670 Int Charges 569,325.75
May 15, 2015 IDA-48670 Int Charges 569,325.75
May 1, 2015 IDA-45780 Int Charges 791,024.40
May 1, 2015 IDA-45780 Int Charges 791,024.40
May 15, 2014 IDA-48670 Int Charges 3,822.07
May 15, 2014 IDA-48670 Int Charges 3,822.07
May 15, 2014 IDA-48670 Int Charges 657,619.50
May 15, 2014 IDA-48670 Int Charges 657,619.50
Nov 15, 2013 IDA-48670 Int Charges 640,677.30
Nov 15, 2013 IDA-48670 Int Charges 640,677.30
Nov 15, 2013 IDA-48670 Int Charges 6,986.34
Nov 15, 2013 IDA-48670 Int Charges 6,986.34
May 1, 2014 IDA-45780 Int Charges 9,720.63
May 1, 2014 IDA-45780 Int Charges 9,720.63
May 1, 2014 IDA-45780 Int Charges 895,329.75
May 1, 2014 IDA-45780 Int Charges 895,329.75
Nov 1, 2013 IDA-45780 Int Charges 5,408.72
Nov 1, 2013 IDA-45780 Int Charges 5,408.72
Nov 1, 2013 IDA-45780 Int Charges 876,720.75
Nov 1, 2013 IDA-45780 Int Charges 876,720.75
Nov 15, 2014 IDA-48670 Int Charges 3,645.24
Nov 15, 2014 IDA-48670 Int Charges 3,645.24
May 15, 2021 IDA-48670 Loan Repay 1,635,801.90
May 15, 2021 IDA-48670 Int Charges 597,438.25
May 15, 2021 IDA-48670 Int Charges 597,438.25
Nov 15, 2020 IDA-48670 Int Charges 8,010.87
Nov 15, 2020 IDA-48670 Int Charges 8,010.87
Nov 15, 2020 IDA-48670 Int Charges 596,009.00
Nov 15, 2020 IDA-48670 Int Charges 596,009.00
May 1, 2021 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 25,112.29
Nov 1, 2021 IDA-45780 Int Charges 403.54
Nov 1, 2021 IDA-45780 Int Charges 403.54
Nov 1, 2021 IDA-45780 Int Charges 783,682.30
Nov 1, 2021 IDA-45780 Int Charges 783,682.30
Nov 1, 2021 IDA-45780 Int Charges 11,621.83
Nov 1, 2021 IDA-45780 Int Charges 11,621.83
Nov 1, 2021 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 2,176,895.20
Nov 1, 2020 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 20,377.74
Nov 1, 2020 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 2,157,782.80
Nov 1, 2020 IDA-45780 Int Charges 317.65
Nov 1, 2020 IDA-45780 Int Charges 317.65
May 8, 2020 IDA-45780 Int Charges 781,197.40
May 8, 2020 IDA-45780 Int Charges 24,488.06
May 8, 2020 IDA-45780 Int Charges 24,488.06
Nov 1, 2020 IDA-45780 Int Charges 800,474.00
Nov 1, 2020 IDA-45780 Int Charges 800,474.00
May 15, 2020 IDA-48670 Int Charges 565.06
May 15, 2020 IDA-48670 Int Charges 565.06
May 15, 2020 IDA-48670 Int Charges 579,609.94
May 15, 2020 IDA-48670 Int Charges 579,609.94
May 8, 2020 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 2,104,235.50
May 8, 2020 IDA-45780 Int Charges 781,197.40
May 1, 2019 IDA-45780 Int Charges 8,824.03
May 1, 2019 IDA-45780 Int Charges 8,824.03
May 1, 2019 IDA-45780 Int Charges 794,006.56
May 1, 2019 IDA-45780 Int Charges 794,006.56
May 15, 2019 IDA-48670 Int Charges 8,966.66
May 15, 2019 IDA-48670 Int Charges 8,966.66
May 15, 2019 IDA-48670 Int Charges 580,424.30
May 15, 2019 IDA-48670 Int Charges 580,424.30
Nov 1, 2019 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 4,050.37
Nov 1, 2019 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 2,125,320.50
Nov 1, 2019 IDA-45780 Int Charges 773,733.50
Nov 1, 2019 IDA-45780 Int Charges 773,733.50
Nov 15, 2019 IDA-48670 Int Charges 4,276.55
Nov 15, 2019 IDA-48670 Int Charges 4,276.55
May 10, 2021 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 2,200,414.00
May 10, 2021 IDA-45780 Int Charges 797,693.94
May 10, 2021 IDA-45780 Int Charges 797,693.94
May 15, 2021 IDA-48670 Int Charges 1,373.90
May 15, 2021 IDA-48670 Int Charges 1,373.90
Nov 15, 2019 IDA-48670 Int Charges 581,208.80
Nov 15, 2019 IDA-48670 Int Charges 581,208.80
May 1, 2018 IDA-45780 Int Charges 7,208.48
May 1, 2018 IDA-45780 Int Charges 7,208.48
May 2, 2018 IDA-45780 Int Charges 821,613.70
May 2, 2018 IDA-45780 Int Charges 821,613.70
May 15, 2018 IDA-48670 Int Charges 4,704.91
May 15, 2018 IDA-48670 Int Charges 4,704.91
May 15, 2018 IDA-48670 Int Charges 604,252.40
May 15, 2018 IDA-48670 Int Charges 604,252.40
Nov 1, 2018 IDA-45780 Int Charges 6,480.86
Nov 1, 2018 IDA-45780 Int Charges 6,480.86
Nov 15, 2018 IDA-48670 Int Charges 10,689.22
Nov 15, 2018 IDA-48670 Int Charges 10,689.22
Nov 15, 2018 IDA-48670 Int Charges 578,420.30
Nov 15, 2018 IDA-48670 Int Charges 578,420.30
Nov 1, 2018 IDA-45780 Int Charges 795,574.40
Nov 1, 2018 IDA-45780 Int Charges 795,574.40
May 1, 2017 IDA-45780 Int Charges 10,575.13
May 1, 2017 IDA-45780 Int Charges 10,575.13
May 2, 2024 IDA-45780 Int Charges 694,059.70
May 2, 2024 IDA-45780 Int Charges 694,059.70
May 1, 2024 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 43,927.70
May 2, 2024 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 1,989,834.00
May 21, 2024 IDA-48670 Int Charges 17,141.49
May 21, 2024 IDA-48670 Int Charges 17,141.49
May 21, 2024 IDA-48670 Loan Repay 1,506,559.10
May 21, 2024 IDA-48670 Int Charges 627.73
May 21, 2024 IDA-48670 Int Charges 627.73
May 21, 2024 IDA-48670 Int Charges 531,062.06
May 21, 2024 IDA-48670 Int Charges 531,062.06
May 14, 2009 IDA-H4770 Loan Commitment 309,776,128.00
Feb 22, 2011 IDA-H6430 Loan Commitment 246,600,000.00
May 14, 2009 IDA-45780 Loan Commitment 230,223,888.00
Feb 22, 2011 IDA-48670 Loan Commitment 173,400,000.00
Dec 5, 2023 IDA-48670 Int Charges 17,770.24
Dec 5, 2023 IDA-48670 Int Charges 17,770.24
Dec 5, 2023 IDA-48670 Loan Repay 1,511,959.90
Dec 5, 2023 IDA-48670 Int Charges 521,432.72
Dec 5, 2023 IDA-48670 Int Charges 521,432.72
Nov 1, 2023 IDA-45780 Int Charges 82.60
Nov 1, 2023 IDA-45780 Int Charges 82.60
Nov 1, 2023 IDA-45780 Int Charges 696,879.75
Nov 1, 2023 IDA-45780 Int Charges 696,879.75
Nov 1, 2023 IDA-45780 Int Charges 31,936.67
Nov 1, 2023 IDA-45780 Int Charges 31,936.67
Nov 1, 2023 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 2,019,941.20
May 1, 2023 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 38,539.25
May 3, 2023 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 2,044,020.10
May 3, 2023 IDA-45780 Int Charges 41.09
May 3, 2023 IDA-45780 Int Charges 41.09
May 3, 2023 IDA-45780 Int Charges 693,385.30
May 15, 2023 IDA-48670 Int Charges 33,317.58
May 15, 2023 IDA-48670 Int Charges 33,317.58
May 15, 2023 IDA-48670 Loan Repay 1,526,604.40
May 15, 2023 IDA-48670 Int Charges 531,635.25
May 15, 2023 IDA-48670 Int Charges 531,635.25
Nov 15, 2022 IDA-48670 Int Charges 511,608.50
Nov 15, 2022 IDA-48670 Int Charges 511,608.50
Nov 15, 2022 IDA-48670 Loan Repay 75,503.41
Nov 15, 2022 IDA-48670 Loan Repay 1,420,754.50
Nov 1, 2022 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 105,555.47
Nov 2, 2022 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 1,874,847.40
Nov 2, 2022 IDA-45780 Int Charges 698,023.70
Nov 2, 2022 IDA-45780 Int Charges 698,023.70
May 3, 2023 IDA-45780 Int Charges 693,385.30
Nov 15, 2021 IDA-48670 Int Charges 593,036.75
Nov 15, 2021 IDA-48670 Int Charges 593,036.75
May 1, 2022 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 26,168.98
May 1, 2022 IDA-45780 Loan Repay 2,048,085.90
May 1, 2022 IDA-45780 Int Charges 738,953.25
May 1, 2022 IDA-45780 Int Charges 738,953.25
May 15, 2022 IDA-48670 Loan Repay 1,480,000.90
May 15, 2022 IDA-48670 Int Charges 556,058.94
May 15, 2022 IDA-48670 Int Charges 556,058.94
May 15, 2022 IDA-48670 Loan Repay 33,084.61
Nov 15, 2021 IDA-48670 Int Charges 15,612.19
Nov 15, 2021 IDA-48670 Int Charges 15,612.19
Nov 15, 2021 IDA-48670 Loan Repay 1,597,405.40

Footnotes

Ratings

IMPLEMENTATION RATINGS

Name Review Date
Counterpart Funding Satisfactory 2013-07-06
Overall Implementation Progress (IP) Satisfactory 2013-07-06
Procurement Moderately Satisfactory 2013-07-06
Overall High 2013-07-06
Progress towards achievement of PDO Moderately Satisfactory 2013-07-06
Financial Management Moderately Satisfactory 2013-07-06
Monitoring and Evaluation Moderately Satisfactory 2013-07-06
Project Management Satisfactory 2013-07-06

COMPLETION RATINGS

INDICATORIMPLEMENTATION COMPLETION & RESULTS REPORT: 12-21-2013
OutcomesSubstantial
Risk to Development OutcomeModest
Bank PerformanceSubstantial
Borrower PerformanceSubstantial
Government PerformanceSubstantial
Implementing AgencySubstantial

INDEPENDENT EVALUATION RATINGS

INDICATORICR REVIEW: 08-04-2014PROJECT PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT REPORT:
Outcome RatingModerately Satisfactory N/a
Risk To Development OutcomeModerateN/a
Bank PerformanceModerately SatisfactoryN/a
Borrower PerformanceModerately SatisfactoryN/a
Government PerformanceModerately SatisfactoryN/a
Implementing AgencyModerately SatisfactoryN/a
Icr QualitySatisfactoryN/a
M&e QualitySubstantialN/a

Results Framework

PROJECT DEVELOPMENT OBJECTIVE INDICATORS

INDICATORBASELINECURRENTTARGET
  • Gender Parity Index for grades 1-4Value93.0093.0094.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2010July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentNew PBS 2 AF indicator
  • Net enrolment rate for grades 1-8Value79.1085.4091.50
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    Comment
  • MeaslesValue68.0079.5086.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    Comment
  • DPT3+HepB3+Hib3Value76.8084.9088.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    Comment
  • Children immunized - under 12 months against DTP3 (number)Value1387351.002070000.001900000.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    Comment
  • Female beneficiariesValue50.0050.0050.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    Comment
  • Primary enrolment ratesValue0.000.000.00
    Date
    CommentSee sub indicators belowDate from Education MISSee sub indicators below
  • Children vaccinatedValue0.000.000.00
    Date
    CommentSee sub indicators belowDate from Health MISSee sub indicators below
  • Children immunized (number)Value1387351.002070000.000.00
    Date
    CommentSee sub indicators belowSee sub indicators below
  • Births attended by skilled health personnelValue16.0021.0048.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    Comment
  • Proportion of malfunctioning water suppliesValue25.0024.0016.00
    DateJuly 1, 2010July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentData from Ministry of Water and Energy survey
  • Farm households receiving agricultural extension servicesValue5090000.0010500000.009960000.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentData from Ministry of Agriculture reports
  • Citizens who report that they have knowledge about the woreda budgetValue9.0050.0013.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentData from Woreda City Benchmarking survey
  • Citizens who report that woreda officials have actively sought the views of people in their kebele on quality of basic servicesValue52.0048.0058.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentWoreda City Benchmarking survey
  • Direct project beneficiariesValue71180257.0081002665.0071180257.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    Commentdata from census/central statistical agencyIs the projected population based on 2007 figures and growth rates, excluding Addis Ababa.

INTERMEDIATE RESULTS INDICATORS

INDICATORBASELINECURRENTTARGET
  • Woredas that post "laypersons" budget and expenditure templatesValue0.0092.0075.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentEMCP reports, field visits
  • Basic service units that post the standardized service delivery template with completed information on budget, resource inputs and service standardsValue0.0050.0050.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentEMCP reports, field visits
  • Woredas where PBS social accountability implementing partners facilitate the use of social accountability toolsValue0.0086.000.00
    Date
    CommentManagement Agency and Steering Committee reports
  • Basic service units that have developed joint action plans for service quality improvement based on interface meetings between service users and providersValue0.000.00344.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012
    CommentManagement Agency and Steering Committee reportsNumber has not been determined
  • Sectors in which systems quality assessments conductedValue0.002.005.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentCentral Statistical Agency data
  • Woredas that rolled out new WASH MISValue0.0058.00200.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentMoWE data
  • CSA branch offices conntectedValue10.0025.0025.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentCSA data
  • OFAGValue32.0096.1270.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentOFAG reports
  • ORAGValue0.0032.2770.00
    DateJuly 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentNo baseline data availabledata from OFAG reportsData not available
  • Proportion of qualified primary school teachersValue38.4055.6061.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2010July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentData from education MIS
  • Ratio of health extension workers to populationsValue1:43691:21371:2500
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentData from Health MIS
  • Woreda road desks with appropriate resourcesValue8.000.00190.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012
    CommentRSDP reports
  • Development agents deployedValue49946.0066000.0071000.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2011July 1, 2012
    CommentMinistry of Agriculture reportsDo not have data from 2001/12
  • Average share of capital expenditures as a share of total spending (LIG woredas)Value7.0030.0030.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2011July 1, 2011
    CommentLIG reports
  • LIG projects with "satisfactory technical quality"Value90.0090.0090.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2010July 1, 2011July 1, 2011
    CommentLIG reports
  • Contraceptive prevalence rateValue33.0029.0055.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentHealth MIS, DHS
  • People with access to a basic package of health, nutrition, or reproductive health services (number)Value71423788.0076477093.0083893376.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2010July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentHealth MIS, DHSBased on figure from JRIS that 91% of population had access
  • Long-lasting insecticide-treated malaria nets purchased and/or distributed (number)Value0.0037600000.0037800000.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentHealth MIS, DHS
  • Regions where standardized audit qualification (IIA qualification) is widely disseminatedValue0.0011.0011.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentOFAG reports
  • Public sector auditors registered and followed up for the CIA qualification trainingValue22.0040.0070.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentOFAG reports
  • Audit coverageValue0.000.000.00
    Date
    CommentSee sub indicators belowData from OFAG reportsSee sub indicators below
  • Regional governments adopting and disseminating Public Procurement Proclamation, Directives and manualValue0.0011.008.00
    DateJanuary 1, 2007July 1, 2012July 1, 2012
    CommentProcurement publications and audit reports